| Year | Grand Master | Distinguished Service Medal recipient | Valentine Reintzel Meritorious Service Medal recipients |
| 1942 | Noble D. Larner | J. Claude Keiper
William T. Ballard
Vernon G. Owen | |
| 1943 | Carl H. Claudy | Joseph H. Milans
L Whiting Estes | |
| 1944 | Aubrey R. Marrs | Charles E. Baldwin | |
| 1945 | Paul R. Mattix | Carl H. Claudy | |
| 1946 | William E. Schooley | John C. Palmer | |
| 1947 | Marvin Farrington | Clark C. Griffith | |
| 1948 | Dean H. Stanley | Beuben A. Bogley, Sr. | |
| 1949 | E.S. Bettleheim, Jr. | none | |
| 1950 | Marvin E. Fowler | Noble D. Larner | |
| 1951 | David S. Davison | Horace S. Naylor | |
| 1952 | Renah F. Camalier | John D. Cunningham | |
| 1953 | Roy D. Borden | none | |
| 1954 | Fred B. Blackburn | none | |
| 1955 | Gregor Macpherson | Harry Silverman | |
| 1956 | Samuel W. McIntosh | Marx E. Kahn | |
| 1957 | R. Baker Harris | William E. Schooley | |
| 1958 | William H. Rohrman | George W. Feidt | |
| 1959 | Reuben A. Bogley, Jr. | Raymond N. Babcock | |
| 1960 | J. August Johnson, Jr. | J. Williamson Cook | |
| 1961 | Ralph M. Wolfe | William H. Rohrman | |
| 1962 | Convass B. Dean | John W. Lainhart | |
| 1963 | Charles B. Gilley | Renah F. Camalier | |
| 1964 | Harry B. Savage | Samuel W. McIntosh | |
| 1965 | Lex L. Dodds | John F. Isaac | |
| 1966 | Thomas W. Dodge | Robert C. Nicholson | |
| 1967 | Charles T. MacDonald | Milton R. Day | |
| 1968 | William P. Jacobs, Jr. | none | |
| 1969 | Milton D. Korman | Paul S. Murphy | |
| 1970 | H. Kenneth Kingsbury | Karl T. Weimer, Jr. | |
| 1971 | Robert F. Sutphin | Isadore Rosenthal | |
| 1972 | N. Norman Engleberg
Frank A. Kenyon | Marvin E. Fowler | |
| 1973 | Frank A. Kenyon | Elmer F. Stein | |
| 1974 | Robert L. Morris | Harold F. Stoll | |
| 1975 | William E. Eccleston | Raymond F. Brown | |
| 1976 | John B. Layton | Judge N. Singleton | |
| 1977 | Charles V. Brewer | George P. Zillig | |
| 1978 | Morris F. Hewitt | Frederick L. Simmons | |
| 1979 | George F. Moyer | William P. jacobs, Jr. | |
| 1980 | Perry A. Lester | Milton Fields | |
| 1981 | John C. Schleter | Kenneth C. Buker | |
| 1982 | Elmer F. Stein | Carl R. LeVine | |
| 1983 | Donald L. Mallorey | Joseph M. Calverwell | |
| 1984 | James M. Burns | Albert C. Allen | |
| 1985 | Theodore M. Kahn | Ernest J. Higgins | |
| 1986 | William C. Miskovic | Julius Gordin | |
| 1987 | L. Robert Baker | Robert F. Drechsler | |
| 1988 | Raymond F. McMullen | Carles A. Carrico | Harold Grainger
Elmer G. "Skinny" Morris
Charles S. McDaniel |
| 1989 | Robert A. Statler | Harold Grainger | Marvin E. Fowler
B. Hope Harrison
Stewart W. Miner |
| 1990 | Charles S. Iversen | John Greenwood | Richard A. Fiedler
Dennis D. Kirk
Richard A. Pychner, Jr. |
| 1991 | Darwin A. Brock | Horace W. Parsley | George R. Kidwell
Carl R. LeVine
Floyd E. Werle |
| 1992 | Jerold J. Samet | John T. Adams | Thomas R. Dougherty
Robert B. Heyat
Bernard E. Schultz |
| 1993 | George R. Adams | Stafford Appel | Donald R. Curry
Jerold J. Samet
M. Marty Youssefiani |
| 1994 | William T. Jenkins | Hugh Y. Bernard | Claude Charbonniaud
Todd C. Duehring
Oscar Rodriguez |
| 1995 | J. Philip Smith | Arthur B. Crown | Walter E. Boomer |
| 1996 | William E. Chaney, Jr. | George R. Kidwell | Jack R. Frazier
Marshall C. Gardner
Frank W. Seal |
| 1997 | Robert F. Drechsler | Stewart W. Miner | Eugene H. "Dutch" Albert
Lemoine V. Dickinson
Thomas W. Jackson |
| 1998 | Eldon J. Brown | Hugh A. Shawen | Robert F. Drechsler
Charles S. Iversen
Cedric L. Smith |
| 1999 | Dan L Frederick | Frank A. Kenyon | Paul M. Bessel
Akram R. Elias
Gerhard Meinzer |
| 2000 | Mansour Hatefi | Gerhard Meinzer | Max Beloff
Mickey Ander
Albert T. Ames |
| 2001 | Grant R. Berning | Walter F. Simon | Bennie G. Owens
Robert H. Starr
Jesse Villarreal |
| 2002 | Robert H. Starr | Robert B. Heyat | José Manuel Collera Vento
Norman Barshai
George J. Stoklas, Jr. |
| 2003 | Jules S. Tepper | Marion Knight Warner | David A. Balcom
Teko A. Foly
Bill F. Greschel |
| 2004 | Gordon Lee Ferguson | David A. Balcom | Nat Granstein
Sam Atkinson
Dean S. Clatterbuck |
| 2005 | Leonard Proden | | |
| 2006 | Albert McNair Smith | | |
